A Latino pope? And thoughts on shame in the school lunch line2/20/2013
The brilliant actress Maggie Smith of “Downton Abbey” quoted the playwright Noel Coward on “60 Minutes” Sunday night in talking about her advancing age. She’s 78.
“It seems like you eat breakfast every 30 minutes,” Smith said, referring to how days go racing by as one matures.
For many Iowa kids, though, it is all about the food. Breakfast isn’t a metaphor. It’s something they apparently skip — or maybe get once every 30 days.
According to the most recent Iowa Kids Count report, in 2011, 38.2 percent of students in Iowa’s public schools were eligible for free-and-reduced lunches.
According to the U.S. Census, the 2011 poverty level for a family of three with two members under the age of 18 was $18,123. For family of four with three members under 18 the poverty level stood at $22,891 in 2011. The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s guidelines for this school year make a student eligible for free lunches if his family is at 130 percent of poverty and reduced lunches if her family is at 185 percent of poverty.
Back in the 1970s and 1980s, when I was in grade school, we all seemed to know at least some of the kids who were on the free-or-reduced program as we went through the lunch lines. We used punch cards then, when theirs ran out, students often purchased new ones in the open, making it easy to tell who was getting a better deal than others. The colors of the cards were different, too. And if you wanted an extra milk or slice of pizza, you’d see the less fortunate paying a dime or two less.
Today, that’s not possible as students key in pin numbers, like at an ATM machine, at higher grade levels, and staff scan rosters for the younger kids.
In the end, no one wants a kid to go hungry because his parents can’t make enough money to pay for the school lunch. Few things in life are more heart-breaking than a hungry kid.
Then again, I’m sure there are many people buying things they don’t need — and not giving a second thought to filling out the paperwork for the free-and-reduced lunches.
What’s more, in the days when we seemed to know who was on the dole, the element of shame perhaps served as a motivator for those kids to work a little harder in class after lunch so they could improve their own stations in life. I’ve interviewed successful people from humble means who have told me as much.
Having just seen the tragic documentary film “Bully” — which doesn’t exactly portray the Sioux City public schools in a positive way — showcasing class divisions, income inequality, among children, is fraught with all sorts of potential for trouble.
But conservatives have fertile and fair ground here. The blind assistance of today’s program shields youngsters from the reality of capitalism. But some day they will face The Big Sort — between the winners and losers in our system.
This sounds harsh. But there are other options. Those eligible for the free-and-reduced lunches can slap away the helping hand. With thrifty shopping, families can send kids to school with healthy affordable sack lunches instead.
School officials tell me this happens as many of the families eligible for the break on lunch just don’t take it.
• • •
Thirty-nine percent of the world’s 1.2 billion Catholics are Latino, and 50 percent of Catholics in the United States under 40 are Latino. The demographic represents a muscular and growing part of the church.
That considered, U.S. Sen.. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, a Catholic who graduated from Des Moines Dowling Catholic High School and Catholic University Law School in Washington, D.C., said the church should consider a Latino pope as a successor for Pope Benedict XVI who announced last Monday that he will resign effective Feb. 28, setting up a papal conclave for March.
“I think it would be a great move in the right direction,” Harkin said of the prospects of a Latino pope.
Harkin’s remarks came during a conference call with Cityview and other media.
“I think it would send a strong signal to the rest of the world,” Harkin said. “I think it would give a new face to the church to do something like that.”
Cardinal Oscar Rodriguez Maradiaga of Honduras is widely reported to be in the running in the papal-selection process, as are other Hispanics.
Timothy Matovina, executive Director of Notre Dame’s Institute for Latino Studies, told NBC Latino that the Honduran cardinal made a favorable impression when he spoke to a national meeting of Latino youth at the university.
“They brought him in, and he was electrifying,” Matovina said in the NBC Latino interview. “Here was a cardinal from Latin America — and he’s one of them. He said in Honduras they miss the people who have left to the U.S. ‘We miss you every day. We minister for the families who weep for you; we dry their tears,’ he said. He was speaking from within the Latino experience. It’s very powerful stuff.”
Harkin said the church doesn’t have to limit itself to the top of its hierarchy in selecting a leader.
“You know, you don’t have to be a cardinal to be a pope,” Harkin said. “You don’t even have to be a bishop to be a pope. They can reach down and pick a priest to be a pope. I’ve met a lot of good priests out there.”
Harkin, 73, said the pope he most admires during his own lifetime is Pope John XXIII, who held the position from 1958 to 1963.
“He opened up the doors and really moved the church forward,” Harkin said. “Since that time, the windows seem to be getting closed again. So I think we need to again revive the spirit of Pope John XXIII, open up the church more, and don’t be afraid of a proliferation of different views and ideas. I never did buy the idea that it was going to get stronger by becoming more narrow and demanding more orthodoxy.” CV
Douglas Burns is a fourth-generation Iowa newspaperman who writes for The Carroll Daily Times Herald and offers columns for Cityview.